English     پارسی
  Contact me News & announcement Weblog About me Home  
 

Estefta [questioning verdicts from religious authorities]

To you Highnesses and honorable religious authorities (MARJAE TAQLID) of Shia,

With greetings and respect
It is kindly noted that it has been a while that a group of people have been conducting meetings in the form of Faradarmani classes claiming healing people, and beside charging people, they have been spreading thoughts such as: contradiction in the verses of the holy Quran, ignorance of prophet Muhammad (PBUH) to the holy Quran, heresy of Tavasol and visiting shrines of Imams (PBUH), sneering at Mahdaviat (Long-awaited twelfth Imam), praising Lucifer and insolence toward Rohaniat (clerics).

According to above we would like to ask for your opinion on:

1- Is this cult a misleading cult?
2- What is the verdict on attending these classes?
3- Are these people -who spread these ideas- considered Muslim?
4- Are the mentioned ideas derived from Islamic opinion?
5- What is the verdict of helping this organization financially?
6- According to the fact that denial of necessities of Islam is observed in their opinion, are they considered as apostate?

Notifications:

• The following ESTEFTAAT [questioning verdicts from religious authorities] has been administrated by the Inquisite and Analysis of newfangled mysticism group of the cultural and advertising institute of EMAM REZA(PBUH) and under my supervision (Mir Hamid Mousavi )
• Comments of the promoting office of QOM’s seminary will be published in this website soon in near future.
• All news agencies, newspapers, magazines, websites and etc have the right to use and publish these Estefta’s even without mentioning the source of the news.
• Commandments of ten other MARJAE TAQLID (Religious authorities) of Shiaat will be published in this website soon in the future.
• The Inquisite and Analysis of newfangled mysticism group of cultural and promoting institute of EMAM REZA (PBUH) is going to publish a separate special issue on study and critics of Erfan Halqeh. Therefore we are ready to receive articles and reports of researchers.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei:



In the name of God His mercy be upon you Avoid attending these meeting and any other activity that helps to spread these thoughts.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi:



In the name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful With greeting; These cults have no religious credibility and the mentioned believes are obvious deviation and their intentions are to fraud and they have prepared these thoughts to gain their desire and some of them have earned huge amount of money in this way, avoid them.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Alavi Gorgani:



In the name of God 1- These cults are considered as misleading cults and are DEVIATIVE. 2- It is forbidden to attend these classes. 3- If they deny the necessities of Islam they are not Muslim or else their approach is not Islamic however they are not pagan in apparent. 4- These thoughts are amongst DEVIATIVE and anti-religious thoughts and are a result of ignorance and pride. 5- It is forbidden to help to spread these thoughts. 6- If they knowingly say such words and if the result is the denial of EMAMAT (Imams) and NABOVAT (prophets) , they are considered apostate.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Mazaheri




In the name of God
1- They are considered as misleading cults.
2- It is forbidden and it is a very big sin.
3- They are not Muslim.
4- It is derived from evils of Jinns and human, and not from dear Islam.
5- It is a very big sin and is helping blasphemy.
6- They are apostates.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani



Answer: if it is a question, attending these kinds of meetings is forbidden.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Safi Golpaygani




In the name of God the Compassionate the Merciful
Greetings to you and his mercy be upon you
I do not know about the matter personally. In general every cult that has the thoughts mentioned in the question is a misleading cult. Attending their meeting and helping them in any way is forbidden. God save us from Evil.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Morteza Tehrani



In the name of God
1- This cult is from the misleading cults of Vahabiat and is apostate because of denying the obvious matters in holy Quran but they are so widespread in Iran that we cannot do anything other than denying them and cutting having relations with them.
2- Definitely forbidden and is of great MOHARMAT (sins).
3- No and if it was at the time of Baqiatallah [Twelfth Imam] they would be sentenced to death.
4- No, they have been inspired by Jewry and are the true atheistic.
5- Is forbidden and is worst than drinking alcohol that has HADD. [Amount of punishment that the judge has not determined.]
6-If they advertise according to its outcome they are apostate, else they are sentenced to TAZIR [Amount of punishment that religion has determined.]


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollaha Rouhani



In the name of God
1- Definitely is a misleading cult and their followers are apostate.
2- Attending these classes is not JAYEZ (permitted).
3- Claimant and the followers of above cult are apostate and are not Muslim.
4- Helping this organization, financially is not JAYEZ (permitted).
5- Yes, are considered as apostate.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Hasani Shahroodi



In the name of God
1- Based on the question yes
2- Is not JAYEZ (permitted)
3- They are deviated people
4- No
5- Is not JAYEZ (permitted)
6- Yes


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Rahmati Sirjani



1- Obviously of the greatest misleading cults
2- Is forbidden
3- No
4- Has no relations to the proper Islamic thoughts
5- Is forbidden
6- If they have the record of Islam, they are apostate



* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Alavi Borujerdi



In the name of God
1- If they believe in what was mentioned in the question, they are considered as misleading cult.
2- It is not permitted to attend such classes with such believes.
3- If these believes and their exposure is to deny prophecy of prophet Mohamad (PBUH) they are not Muslim.
4- This thought is against Islamic thoughts.
5- Any help to this organization is forbidden.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Gherami



In the name of God
1- Definitely is a misleading cult.
2- Except for the experts to answer the questions, being present there is forbidden.
3- They are apostate.
4- No, these thoughts are atheistic.
5- Helping them is definitely forbidden.
6- If they were Muslim, with these thoughts, they are apostate.
All of these is true in case they deny prophecy of Mohamad (PBUH) , VAHY(revelation) and Quran.


* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Bathai Golpaygani



Answer:
In the name of God

Greetings to you and his mercy be upon you. Wishing success, insight and guidance for you and all truth seekers. According to what you have mentioned, the answers to your six questions are:


First, The authorities of Faradarmani are Zionist and from Vahabiat and even if they were Muslims they are INNATE apostates and the sentence for the INNATE apostates, according to Islam is execution.
Secondly, Attending these classes means helping blasphemy and any help (verbally or financially) to them will raise the rage of God and the punishment in this world as well as the afterlife world.



* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ayatollah Yusef Sanei




In the name of God
With greetings
Attending such classes that causes the spreading of vain believes and any kind of help to them is not JAYEZ. (permitted)

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *


 
Faradarmani    
Psymentology    
Articles    
Questions    
Books    
Magazines    
Interviews    
Awards    
Links